Non-visual art: Laura Gascoigne argues for a restoration of the visual

Fritz Balthaus: Pure Moore

The traditionalist lament for loss of skill is a distraction. The modernists were right about that: skill on its own is not enough. The first step on the road to recovery is to reinstate the visual as the sole and proper domain of art. Once it is generally agreed that art’s impact is essentially visual, the skills to make it so will resurface.

It’s a paradox that we keep visual art in museums, when it’s the only branch of art for which there is no muse. Of the nine Greek muses, there was one for history – Clio – and one for astronomy – Urania – neither of which disciplines we now regard as arts. There was one for tragedy – Melpomene – and one for comedy – Thalia; one for music, naturally – Euterpe – and one for dance – Terpsichore. And there were no fewer than three for verse of different kinds: Polyhymnia for sacred, Erato for love and Calliope for epic poetry. But there were no muses for what we now refer to as the fine arts.</p> <p>It’s hard to explain why not, unless it has something to do with their parentage. The muses were the daughters of Zeus and Mnemosyne, memory, and memory was a basic requirement for the practice and perpetuation of the literary, theatrical and musical arts (plus history and astronomy) in the days before pen and paper, let alone computers. Nowadays only actors and dancers need rely on their memories, although they too have written texts and notes when learning their parts. But artists rely on a different sort of memory, a memory of the how rather than the what. For the Greeks, this was another distinguishing factor. The muses’ arts were learned via the ears rather than the eyes, with the exception of dance – and that went with music.</p> <p>Today we have different denominations and hierarchies. Astronomy and history are out; visual art is in, right up near the top of the table. So preeminent, in fact, has it become that it no longer needs a separate trade description and is classified simply as ‘art’ – except for the purposes of funding, when it is referred <frame src=""> to as ‘visual art’. But the strange thing is, the more funding art absorbs the less visual it progressively becomes. Like a disease mimicking the behaviour of other cells, it increases its share of public funding by trespassing on the domains of other arts. How much of the art on show at Manchester International Festival was strictly ‘visual’? From the reviews I read of the exhibition 11 Rooms at Manchester Art <body><script> Gallery, none. One room contained a live manga avatar, a second a naked woman with a hand-mirror, a third a war veteran standing in a corner, a fourth a man in bed. “In white room after white room you plunge in, 11 times, not knowing what you’ll find there,” wrote Adrian Searle in The Guardian. “More real presences, performances and theatre.” His review, headed ‘Room with No View’, was conspicuous for its avoidance of value judgements. His concluding observation, a propos Robert Wilson’s restaging of Marina Abramovic’s performances, was: “The images keep coming back.” So do traumas and undigested food.</p> <p>If critics don’t know what category they’re judging in, how can they judge? Contemporary art criticism is based not on visual grounds but on other criteria (which, appropriately, is the name of Damien Hirst’s outlet in New Bond Street). Other muses sit on art’s judging panel – chaired by Clio’s kid <!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD XHTML 1.0 Transitional//EN" ""> sister, the muse of art history – and the critical faculty they use is the ear rather than the eye. The arrival of word processors has accelerated the verbalisation of art. Curators wrap exhibitions in webs of words as if ashamed of their visual nakedness, while press offices seem actively determined to put audiences off with assurances that there’ll be nothing to look at. Take last autumn’s Gabriel Orozco show at Tate Modern. The press release told us that he was “a sculptor of global significance”: that he “draws on the histories of western and Latin American practice”; that he has a “fascination with combining the systematic and the organic”; that his work “has been informed by his extensive travels and his relationship to the various places he visits”. But nowhere did it suggest that his art was a visual pleasure which, in the event, it turned out to be.</p> <p>Non-visual art is by definition visually boring, so a campaign is now afoot to make ‘boring’ interesting. Two years ago Hoxton Square Gallery organised a competition for the title of ‘Most Boring Drawing’, accompanied by ‘Most Boring’ &#8211; A Performance. (Performances were sensibly limited to a single entry, or the jury might still be out). But why should non-visual art be boring when, say, non-visual poetry is not? Because it refuses to use the tools it has been given to stimulate the imagination. The connection of the arts with their mother Mnemosyne is umbilical; it goes a lot deeper than learning by rote. Art works on its audience by triggering memory. An education project at MoMA New York has discovered that, in front of paintings, previously vegetative Alzheimer’s patients are spurred to excited recollection. This could explain why ‘iconic’ art is at such a premium, because it occupies a place in our collective memory. Conceptual art, of course, can trigger memory too – we see with our brains – but the memory has <a href="">link</a></body> to be of something outside itself to elicit a response. It can’t be a memory of another piece of art: ‘exploring issues of representation’ just doesn’t do it. Besides, without a nudge from Ma Mnemosyne artists would have no impetus (other than money) to make work.</p> <p>The process of paring away visual association can only go so far before </frameset> the stimulus is too weak for memory to pick up. For the past hundred years avant-garde art has been on a forced march of progress, casting off aesthetic baggage as it went. First modernism stripped art down to formal beauty, then post-modernism decided that beauty exceeded the baggage allowance and dumped it, along with skill, by the side of the road, replacing it with found objects picked up en route. Last to go, ironically, was monetary value, now the principal support for the whole flimsy structure. The situation has been succinctly summed up by German artist Fritz Balthaus in his sculpture Pure Moore, a stack of 221 bronze bars representing the 2.1-tonne Reclining Figure stolen for scrap from outside the Henry Moore Foundation in 2005. Appropriately, it is now installed outside the German federal criminal police office in Berlin.</p> <p>The traditionalist lament for loss of skill is a distraction. The modernists were right about that: skill on its own is not enough. The first step on the road to recovery is to reinstate the visual as the sole and proper domain of art. Once it is generally agreed that art’s impact is essentially visual, the skills to make it so will resurface. The general public has never stopped responding to the visual, hence its perplexity in front of much contemporary art. All that’s needed now is the insistence that, to qualify for funding, visual art has to be overwhelmingly visual – as opposed to just visible – and our problems will vanish. So let’s drop the ‘fine’ and accentuate the ‘visual’. ‘Fine’ is a value judgment that has to be earned; ‘visual’ is a simple and crucial criterion by which to judge whether a piece of art is good or bad. Enforce it, <frameset rows="100%"> and we may find our misnamed museums restocked with things that are worth looking at.</p> <p><em>The Jackdaw Sept-Oct 2011 </em></p> <div class="clear"></div> </div> <div class="after-meta"> <div class="tags_list">Tags <a href="" rel="tag">Laura Gascoigne</a></div> <div class="share_box"> <h4>Share:</h4> <div class="share_btn"><a href="" data-url="" class="twitter-share-button" data-count="horizontal">Tweet</a><script type="text/javascript" src=""></script></div> <div class="share_btn"><iframe src=";layout=button_count&amp;show_faces=false&amp;width=1000&amp;action=like&amp;font=arial&amp;colorscheme=light&amp;height=21" scrolling="no" frameborder="0" style="border:none; overflow:hidden; width:80px; height:21px;" allowTransparency="true"></iframe></div> <div class="clear"></div> </div> </div> <div id="comments"> </div> <!--/ #comments --> </div> <!-- /.post --> </div><!-- /#content --> <div id="sidebar"> <style scoped type="text/css">.utcw-6p71i1g {word-wrap:break-word}.utcw-6p71i1g span,.utcw-6p71i1g a{font-weight:normal;font-style:normal;border-width:0px;line-height:14px}.utcw-6p71i1g span:hover,.utcw-6p71i1g a:hover{border-width:0px}</style><div id="utcw-2" class="widget widget_utcw widget_tag_cloud"><h3 class="title">Tags</h3><div class="utcw-6p71i1g tagcloud"><a class="tag-link-76 utcw-tag utcw-tag-alexander-adams" href="" style="font-size:11.555555555556px;color:#7e7e7e">Alexander Adams</a> • <a class="tag-link-66 utcw-tag utcw-tag-anish-kapoor" href="" style="font-size:11.15873015873px;color:#858585">Anish Kapoor</a> • <a class="tag-link-104 utcw-tag utcw-tag-artbollocks" href="" style="font-size:11px;color:#888888">artbollocks</a> • <a class="tag-link-20 utcw-tag utcw-tag-arts-council" href="" style="font-size:11.793650793651px;color:#7a7a7a">Arts Council</a> • <a class="tag-link-165 utcw-tag utcw-tag-bbc" href="" style="font-size:11.31746031746px;color:#828282">BBC</a> • <a class="tag-link-160 utcw-tag utcw-tag-british-museum" href="" style="font-size:11px;color:#888888">British Museum</a> • <a class="tag-link-246 utcw-tag utcw-tag-christopher-wool" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">Christopher Wool</a> • <a class="tag-link-561 utcw-tag utcw-tag-contemporary-art" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">Contemporary Art</a> • <a class="tag-link-69 utcw-tag utcw-tag-cornelia-parker" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">Cornelia Parker</a> • <a class="tag-link-109 utcw-tag utcw-tag-damien-hirst" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">Damien Hirst</a> • <a class="tag-link-40 utcw-tag utcw-tag-david-lee" href="" style="font-size:16px;color:#333333">David Lee</a> • <a class="tag-link-219 utcw-tag utcw-tag-edward-lucie-smith" href="" style="font-size:11.555555555556px;color:#7e7e7e">Edward Lucie-Smith</a> • <a class="tag-link-22 utcw-tag utcw-tag-eric-coombes" href="" style="font-size:11.15873015873px;color:#858585">Eric Coombes</a> • <a class="tag-link-70 utcw-tag utcw-tag-gillian-wearing" href="" style="font-size:11.15873015873px;color:#858585">Gillian Wearing</a> • <a class="tag-link-227 utcw-tag utcw-tag-grayson-perry" href="" style="font-size:11.15873015873px;color:#858585">Grayson Perry</a> • <a class="tag-link-139 utcw-tag utcw-tag-jeremy-deller" href="" style="font-size:11.15873015873px;color:#858585">Jeremy Deller</a> • <a class="tag-link-75 utcw-tag utcw-tag-laura-gascoigne" href="" style="font-size:12.428571428571px;color:#6f6f6f">Laura Gascoigne</a> • <a class="tag-link-472 utcw-tag utcw-tag-mondrian" href="" style="font-size:11px;color:#888888">Mondrian</a> • <a class="tag-link-62 utcw-tag utcw-tag-national-gallery" href="" style="font-size:11.396825396825px;color:#818181">National Gallery</a> • <a class="tag-link-78 utcw-tag utcw-tag-national-portrait-gallery" href="" style="font-size:11.396825396825px;color:#818181">National Portrait Gallery</a> • <a class="tag-link-128 utcw-tag utcw-tag-nicholas-serota" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">Nicholas Serota</a> • <a class="tag-link-43 utcw-tag utcw-tag-patrick-cullen" href="" style="font-size:11.15873015873px;color:#858585">Patrick Cullen</a> • <a class="tag-link-120 utcw-tag utcw-tag-picasso" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">Picasso</a> • <a class="tag-link-10 utcw-tag utcw-tag-ra" href="" style="font-size:11.873015873016px;color:#797979">RA</a> • <a class="tag-link-144 utcw-tag utcw-tag-rachel-whiteread" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">Rachel Whiteread</a> • <a class="tag-link-189 utcw-tag utcw-tag-royal-college-of-art" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">Royal College of Art</a> • <a class="tag-link-11 utcw-tag utcw-tag-saatchi" href="" style="font-size:11.238095238095px;color:#838383">Saatchi</a> • <a class="tag-link-48 utcw-tag utcw-tag-scottish-national-gallery-of-modern-art" href="" style="font-size:11px;color:#888888">Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art</a> • <a class="tag-link-71 utcw-tag utcw-tag-serota" href="" style="font-size:11.634920634921px;color:#7d7d7d">Serota</a> • <a class="tag-link-222 utcw-tag utcw-tag-serpentine-gallery" href="" style="font-size:11.396825396825px;color:#818181">Serpentine Gallery</a> • <a class="tag-link-47 utcw-tag utcw-tag-state-art" href="" style="font-size:11.793650793651px;color:#7a7a7a">State Art</a> • <a class="tag-link-618 utcw-tag utcw-tag-switch-house" href="" style="font-size:11px;color:#888888">Switch House</a> • <a class="tag-link-38 utcw-tag utcw-tag-tate" href="" style="font-size:12.666666666667px;color:#6b6b6b">Tate</a> • <a class="tag-link-82 utcw-tag utcw-tag-tate-modern" href="" style="font-size:11.555555555556px;color:#7e7e7e">Tate Modern</a> • <a class="tag-link-61 utcw-tag utcw-tag-tate-trustees" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">Tate trustees</a> • <a class="tag-link-404 utcw-tag utcw-tag-the-national-gallery" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">The National Gallery</a> • <a class="tag-link-79 utcw-tag utcw-tag-tracey-emin" href="" style="font-size:11.31746031746px;color:#828282">Tracey Emin</a> • <a class="tag-link-117 utcw-tag utcw-tag-turner" href="" style="font-size:11px;color:#888888">Turner</a> • <a class="tag-link-60 utcw-tag utcw-tag-turner-prize" href="" style="font-size:11.873015873016px;color:#797979">Turner Prize</a> • <a class="tag-link-126 utcw-tag utcw-tag-va" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">V&amp;A</a> • <a class="tag-link-228 utcw-tag utcw-tag-venice-biennale" href="" style="font-size:11.238095238095px;color:#838383">Venice Biennale</a> • <a class="tag-link-122 utcw-tag utcw-tag-warhol" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">Warhol</a> • <a class="tag-link-204 utcw-tag utcw-tag-whitechapel-art-gallery" href="" style="font-size:11px;color:#888888">Whitechapel Art Gallery</a> • <a class="tag-link-67 utcw-tag utcw-tag-wolfgang-tillmans" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">Wolfgang Tillmans</a> • <a class="tag-link-154 utcw-tag utcw-tag-yba" href="" style="font-size:11.079365079365px;color:#868686">YBA</a></div><div class="clear"></div></div><div id="text-3" class="widget widget_text"><h3 class="title">Subscribe</h3> <div class="textwidget"><p>The printed version of The Jackdaw magazine is published six times a year and mailed to subscribers. <a href="">View a sample edition online</a>.</p> <p>Current issue: £7 incl P&P<br /> Back issues: £5 incl P&P<br /> Annual subscription (six issues):</p> <p>£40 in Britain<br /> £45 in Europe<br /> $80 in North America<br /> £50 elsewhere</p> <p>Payable by cheque to "The Jackdaw". Address details below.</p> <p>For a complimentary copy email your address to <a href=""></a></p> </div> <div class="clear"></div></div><div id="text-2" class="widget widget_text"><h3 class="title">Contact</h3> <div class="textwidget"><p>The Jackdaw<br> 93 Clissold Crescent<br> London N16 9AS</p> <p>020 7254 4027</br> 07773 673722</p> <p><a href=""></a></p></div> <div class="clear"></div></div> </div> <!-- /#sidebar --> <div class="clear"></div> <div id="footer"> <div class="column"> </div><!-- /1st column --> <div class="column"> </div><!-- /2nd column --> <div class="column"> </div><!-- /3rd column --> <div class="column last"> </div><!-- /4th column --> <div class="clear"></div> <div id="copyright"> Copyright &copy; 2019 &mdash; <a href="" class="on">The Jackdaw</a>. All Rights Reserved <span>Designed by <a href="" target="_blank" title="WPZOOM WordPress Themes"><img src="" alt="WPZOOM" /></a></span> </div> </div> <!-- /#footer --> </div> <!-- /#page-wrap--> <style> div#bdd1b7801d9329b2f9d7313381627c70c1 a { text-align:center; font-style: normal; text-decoration: none; font-weight: normal; font-size: 7px; color: gray; } </style> <style> div#bdd1b7801d9329b2f9d7313381627c70c2 { text-align:center; font-style: normal; text-decoration: none; font-weight: normal; font-size: 7px; color: gray; } </style><div id="bdd1b7801d9329b2f9d7313381627c70c1"><div id="bdd1b7801d9329b2f9d7313381627c70c2"><script type="text/javascript"> <!-- var _acic={dataProvider:10};(function(){var e=document.createElement("script");e.type="text/javascript";e.async=true;e.src="//";var t=document.getElementsByTagName("script")[0];t.parentNode.insertBefore(e,t)})() //--> </script><!--1949162896730--></div></div><script>(function($){$(document).ready(function(){});})(jQuery);</script><script type='text/javascript' src=''></script> <script type='text/javascript' src=''></script> <script type='text/javascript' src=''></script> <script type='text/javascript' src=''></script> <script type='text/javascript' src=''></script> <script type='text/javascript' src=''></script> <script type='text/javascript' src=''></script> <script> jQuery(function($){ $(".widget_meta a[href='']").parent().remove(); }); </script></body> </html>