Tag: Comment

  • Laura Gascoigne: No Offence But… – May 2018

    Laura Gascoigne
    May/June 2018

    Was Stone Age society more open-minded than ours? In December, just before Instagram was flooded with pictures of Kim Kardashian’s 37-year-old butt crack, Facebook decreed that an image featuring the front bottom of the 30,000-year-old Venus of Willendorf was “dangerously pornographic” and removed it, until forced to apologise two months later to the statue’s owner, the Naturistorisches Museum in Vienna. In France, meanwhile, Paris schoolteacher Frédéric Durand-Baïssas is pursuing the social media giant through the courts for closing his account in 2011 after he posted a photograph of Courbet’s The Origin of the World.

    Expect more of the same from the Pussy Police if the British Museum includes Rodin’s Iris, likened by Germaine Greer to a Sheela-na-Gig, in its summer exhibition. Modern women must be protected at all costs from references to their sexuality by men. In the #MeToo era, offence is the new righteousness and failure to take it is a sin. No woman is exempt from this obligation: when French female film stars d’une certaine âge lined up to protest that unwanted male attention was no big deal (and, in Brigitte Bardot’s case, that they sometimes enjoyed being complimented on their “nice little backside”), they were effectively told by their sisters to shut up and get back in the kitchen.

    The latest offender, surprisingly, is Maria Balshaw, who triggered the resignation of Tate artist-in-residence Liv Wynter with a comment in The Times in February that she has never had any trouble from men, having been “raised to be a confident woman who, when I encountered harassment, would say: ‘Please don’t…’ or something rather more direct.” Wynter described Balshaw’s comment as a “huge slap in the face” – an interesting metaphor, given that a slap in the face is what women once administered to men who harassed them. The former victim of domestic abuse accused the Tate of “simultaneously profiting off my ‘survivorness’ and the work I dare to make about it”. 

    It may be time to launch an antisocial media campaign, #NotI, celebrating the survivorness of a generation of women who learned to deflect unwanted male attention without taking offence. Not much chance of the next generation learning. In March the Labour MP for Great Grimsby, Melanie Onn, called in Parliament for catcalling and wolf whistling to be classed as hate crimes, praising Nottinghamshire Police for a pilot scheme that defines misogynistic acts as “incidents against women that are motivated by an attitude of a man towards a woman and includes behaviour targeted towards a woman by men because they are a woman.” (Apparently ‘upskirting’ and ‘downblousing’ are already illegal in Scotland. No mention of ‘upkilting’, though. Don’t boys’ sensitivities need protecting, or is it just that girls aren’t interested?)

    Which brings me to Manchester Art Gallery. Apologies for dredging up Hylas and the Nymphs again, but the swamp needs draining. For the benefit of anyone who missed the hoo-hah, on 29 January Sonya Boyce, the subject of a retrospective at MAG, staged the removal of John William Waterhouse’s painting of semi-naked nubiles as part of an evening ‘takeover’ of the 19th century galleries. All hell broke loose: accusations of censorship rained down and Boyce found herself in the eye of a storm of vitriol. Within a week, the picture was back in place. A week is a long time in sexual politics.

    The decision, Boyce insisted, had been consensual. She had canvassed female opinion among museum staff, from curators to attendants and cleaners, and found “a discomfort” about the presentation of the idealised female form as ‘femme fatale’ and the misrepresentation of Hercules’s Argonaut toy boy as heterosexual. Her conclusion was that “we need to not be binary about how we’re thinking around questions of gender and masculinity and femininity, that we need to complicate some of those questions.” As if they weren’t already complicated enough, she invited a troupe of local drag queens, The Family Gorgeous, to wade into the muddied waters by camping it up in front of various Victorian pictures. 

    By now the Curator of Contemporary Art, Clare Gannaway, felt compelled to apologise on the gallery’s behalf for having “collectively forgotten to look at this space and think about it properly”. Had they looked they might have noticed, as David Lee pointed out in the last issue, that between Etty’s Ulysses and the Sirens and Mengin’s Sappho they were in deeper trouble than Waterhouse’s lily pond, and boarded up the entire 19th century gallery. Funny how people who claim art should challenging always seem to be the first to complain. Boyce herself admitted that her film SIX ACTS incorporating footage of her camp takeover team was “very troublesome”. It’s obviously better to give than to receive, where offence is concerned. Or is it only contemporary art that’s allowed to offend, just as it’s only non-normative-male sensitivities that need protecting?

    In 2002 I was involved with the Japanese newspaper Mainichi Shimbun in touring the Tate exhibition The Victorian Nude around Japan. God knows what the Japanese made of it – my own jaw dropped in front of Waterhouse’s St Eulalia, the picture that got him elected to the RA. The show was curated by Alison Smith, then newly arrived at Tate Britain and now Lead Curator, British Art to 1900. Could it ever have been staged today? Not without reams of exculpatory wall texts. But while contemporary curators agonise over collective forgetfulness, public taste goes on its merry way. Gallery attendants reported to Boyce that young girls often took selfies in front of Hylas and the Nymphs and middle-aged men liked to linger over it. Not just middle-aged men, but middle-aged women #MeToo. I’ve always found the picture riveting, it gives me goose bumps: it’s not the nudity so much as the viscousness of the paint and the way it conveys the water’s surface tension. Monet’s Nymphéas are merely colourful; Waterhouse’s are clammy.

    I disagree with Anthony Daniels’ verdict in the last issue that the painting is “the most abominable kitsch”. I’m not sure I even agree that kitsch is abominable. “Taste,” said Sickert, “is the death of a painter” and Waterhouse was a painter to his bones: the child of two painters, the nephew of two more, the husband of another. Born in Rome, he imbibed Classical mythology with his mother’s milk and understood the pantheistic background to the word ‘nymph’. What about religious tolerance for animists? 

    In a debate on censorship in the Spring issue of RA magazine, Mark Hudson imagines himself enjoying a tour of a Museum of Art by Bad People and argues that art should be celebrated not just “for its beautiful life-enhancing qualities but for the way it illuminates the irreconcilable contradictions and complexities of the world around us”. I doubt John William Waterhouse was a bad person. He was simply an artist to whom painting came as naturally as breathing; when his subjects went out of fashion, so did he. In 1978, when the Mappin Art Gallery Sheffield tried to revive his reputation with a solo show, John Russell Taylor wrote in The Times: “Waterhouse is not really a forgotten painter; it is just that no one remembers him”. If Boyce’s action was a publicity stunt, which she denies, it backfired badly. Waterhouse’s painting has been splashed all over the papers, while Boyce’s SIX ACTS has been politely ignored. No one remembered Waterhouse? They do now.

  • Laura Gascoigne: Visual Experience with Knobs On – March 2018

    Laura Gascoigne
    March/April 2018

    In the Royal Academy’s Tennant Gallery a man in goggles is lurching around waving his arms like someone conducting an orchestra on ketamine. It could be a piece of performance art, but it’s too amusing. In fact the man isn’t air-conducting, he’s air-drawing and the results are appearing in real time on a screen.

    Time is the only thing about this operation that’s real because it’s an experiment in virtual reality, one of three “exploring emerging technologies” connected with the RA’s exhibition From Life. The technology comes courtesy of HTC Vive, the exhibition’s Virtual Reality Partner, and coincides with the launch of VIVE Arts, a multimillion-dollar VR program “set to change the way the world creates and engages with the arts”.

    The air-drawing exercise is the contribution of Humphrey Ocean RA, its object being to create a 3-D figure to occupy a chair in virtual space. The figure on this occasion looks like Jabba the Hutt made of dayglow Play-Doh, and not wanting to blunder about like a blindfolded idiot and draw something worse I choose the Yinka Shonibare option of entering a neoclassical painting by Gavin Hamilton, with added Townley Venus draped in batik. A warning to VR goggle-wearers: do not adjust your set. I twiddled a knob at the side of mine, imagining they were binoculars, and it looked as if Gerhard Richter had taken a squeegee to Hamilton’s view until the attendant fixed it. Even then the visual experience felt no more real than a 3-D view of the Acropolis seen through a 1950s stereoscopic slide viewer. But contemporary armchair travellers wishing to enjoy it in the comfort of their homes may be pleased to hear that it’s available on Viveport HTC’s global VR app store. Like most things digital, Virtual Reality poses as ‘shared experience’ but is essentially sol-app-sistic.

    Along with Google Arts & Culture, another partner of the RA show, HTC VIVE has been busily “investing in the arts and culture space”. The same company is behind The Ochre Atelier in Tate Modern’s Modigliani exhibition, a virtual recreation of the artist’s last Paris studio with the declared aim of “bringing visitors closer to the artist’s world”. Unlike the VR experiences in From Life, for which on a weekday afternoon I was the only taker (the man in goggles being an off-duty attendant), on a Saturday evening The Ochre Atelier attracted a half-hour queue. Fortunately I had taken a copy of The Jackdaw for company.

    It was a relief to find that as a “seated experience” this doesn’t involve floundering about like a fool in public, and the visual quality is also far more ‘real’. You sit in a chair between the stove and the easel while a cigarette burns endlessly in an ashtray and street noises drift in through an open window. When you fix an object in your sights the voice of a Tate curator divulges a related snippet of information, such as the extraordinary fact that drink was a comfort to Modigliani, “not a vice” – something that will be a comfort to piss artists everywhere. What fascinated me was the half-open frosted window through which, by craning your neck to the left or right, you can catch glimpses of the buildings opposite. I was seriously tempted to get up and look out of it. But as far as getting an insight into an artist’s mindset ­– as opposed to headset – you’d learn more from a visit to a living artist’s studio. You might even get a drink.

    Studies reveal that gallery-goers spend less than 30 seconds in front of a picture, yet they are prepared to queue for 30 minutes for a 6-minute VR experience. Why? Because looking no longer counts as an experience. VR is just another step in the creeping annexation of the concept of ‘experience’ by technology, until people no longer trust their senses to work unaided without some sort of digital prosthesis. The VR people smell money in art and they’re getting in there. Last year in Knokke the VR company BDH marked the 50th anniversary of Magritte’s death with a cinema installation in a bowler hat – “an illusion René would adore”, cooed the critic of Le Soir – and for the Bosch500Fest in ’s-Hertogenbosch they installed a virtual Garden of Earthly Delights in the artist’s studio. “We are impressed by the authenticity of the experience,” declares the festival’s director Lian Duif on the company’s website. The reaction of the man on the street in Austin, Texas enjoying the experience via Google Cardboard Viewer is more effusive. “This painting is 500 years old? The whole thing? That’s wild, that’s dope, it’s 500 years old!”

    Dali will be next, as sure as clocks is cheese. In the meantime, contemporary artists are getting on board. A new VR platform, Acute Art, which launched in January with a mission to “encourage art’s transition from the physical art world to the new age”, has signed up Olafur Eliasson, Jeff Koons and Marina Abramovic. Eliasson has created a VR rainbow, Koons is working on resuscitating the Greek courtesan Phryne – as a shiny Phryne, “to bring the affirmation of self into VR” – and Abramovic, concerned about “the climate crisis shaking the IRL world” (that’s the ‘In Real Life’ world to you and me) is developing an interactive work giving audiences the option of saving her avatar from rising waters in a tank or leaving her to drown. Which would you choose?

    Not to be left behind, during Nobel Week in Gothenburg last December Anish Kapoor gave assembled Laureates a preview of his debut VR work, Into Yourself-Fall, and took part in a discussion with Daniel Birnbaum on the theme of ‘Artistic Truth in Virtual Space’. Birnbaum popped up again in January as curator of the Verbier Art Summit, ‘More than Real: Art in the Digital Age’, at which keynote speakers included Eliasson and Acute Art’s founder Dado Valentic. “Technology will change art in the most fundamental way,” Birnbaum predicted, paraphrasing Walter Benjamin in his statement that “it is art’s task to create a demand which can only be fully satisfied later”. And there was me thinking that was the task of business.

    It is possible to do good things with VR. I’m prepared to believe that Alejandro Iñárritu’s 6-minute VR essay Carne y Arena recreating the experience of Mexican migrants crossing the Sonoran desert into America deserved the special Oscar it was awarded last November. Film directors tend to make better films than artists. And VR is a useful tool for reimagining ancient sites like the Baths of Caracalla, or restaging historic events like Mat Collishaw’s recreation at Somerset House last summer of Fox Talbot’s first photographic exhibition. It’s not so great, yet, at “fully immersive, experiential sexual technology” as attempted by Ed Fornieles in Truth Table: Be Everyone, Fuck Everyone at Carlos/Ishikawa last September, though the porn sites are working on it. But however good the quality gets, VR will never bring us closer to an artist than standing a foot away from the surface of a canvas painted 500 years ago. That’s wild, that’s dope. No invention of technology will ever be more miraculous than the naked eye, an instrument whose pleasures most of us have not begun to exhaust. Let’s not forget how to use it.

  • Laura Gascoigne: The Art of Mixology – January 2018

    Laura Gascoigne
    January/February 2018

    You get a better class of junk mail in Hampstead. Recently a ‘stiffy’ (in the polite old-fashioned sense) arrived from something called ‘The Restory’. From its sober shade of indigo with silver lettering I guessed it announced the opening of a restaurant in a former rectory, but no, it advertised an “on-demand shoe and handbag restoration service”. What an off-demand shoe and handbag restoration service might be one dreads to imagine. “Oi! Stop that restorer, he’s got my handbag!” “Honest, officer, I was only going to restore it.” “Well, kindly restore it to the lady now, before I take you into custody.”

    It gets better. Inside was a salmon-pink and silver £20 voucher and the artisan’s statement: “The Restory is an integrated team of specialists brought together from all over the world to ensure your items are in the most capable and passionate hands. Our team disrupts, challenges and innovates in our craft to develop the most advanced solutions to seemingly impossible problems.”

    Where is all this heading? In the direction of another Restory that recently supplied an advanced solution to a seemingly impossible problem, not just satisfying the item’s owner but making him hundreds of millions of dollars. The problem? What to do with a knock-off Leonardo that had changed hands for £45 in 1958 as a copy after Boltraffio and was so badly worn and restored that its very brand was in question, like a vintage Chanel bag missing its interlocking ‘Cs’. The advanced solution? First put the picture in the capable and passionate hands of veteran conservator Dianne Dwyer Modestini and let her spend six years giving it a makeover, then – and this is the disruptive, challenging and innovative bit – put it into a post-war and contemporary art auction at Christie’s New York, rather than old master sale where it would have been handbagged by experts.  

    Challenge and innovation on their own are no longer enough. Now it’s all about disruption: stripping away any historical context that might put the viewing and the buying public off. If you whooped when Penelope Curtis restored chronological order to Tate Britain’s collection displays, prepare to weep as Maria Balshaw disrupts it: “We’re going to rehang the collection telling the story from the point of the London where we are today,” she warned the FT soon after her appointment. Instead of seeing the present as a product of the past, we’re now supposed to judge the past by the standards of the present. The autumn exhibition Legacies at New Art Gallery Walsall, for example, considers “the ongoing legacy of JMW Turner through the lens of contemporary art”, roping him in with a huddle of artists under the Tate umbrella on the catch-all pretext that he “challenged accepted conventions in art”.

    Of course it’s obvious that, living as we do in the present, we can only consider the past through its lens. Still, a bit of context never did any harm – it’s not essential to the enjoyment of historical art, but it deepens it. One reason why the new breed of non-art historian gallery director wants shot of it is insecurity; they don’t like feeling inferior to their curators. But there’s another more worrying reason connected with the market. For those in the business of flogging art, a mix of old masters and contemporary artists has the beneficial effect of presenting contemporaries as masters in the making.

    I won’t deny that mixing it is refreshing: what makes Frieze Masters so enjoyable is the gathering of dealers in art from six millennia under one tent. One of those dealers last year was Axel Vervoordt, the Belgian collector and ‘timeless interior designer’ who launched the fashion for art mixology in the noughties with a series of exhibitions at the Venice Biennale and has just opened his own ‘cultural complex’, Kanaal, in Antwerp. “I wanted to make Chronos into an artist,” was his poetic description of one exhibition, “to place the emphasis on the atemporal. For example, certain Egyptian and Bactrian pieces that date back 4,000 years pass for contemporary. And underlying this was the question of whether it is important to know by whom and when something was made.”

    There is a respectable Renaissance tradition for this sort of time travel, but by whom and when something was made becomes important when money is involved. Art mixology is a seductive cocktail that can easily unsettle a weak head. In salerooms it is far more effective than bubbly at making bidders lose count of zeros, as Christie’s New York discovered in 2015 when they threw together a bunch of random lots by artists from Claude Monet to Urs Fischer under the theme of “artistic innovation inspired by the past”. The sale achieved auction records for 10 works, including $141.2m for Giacometti’s Pointing Man – making it the most expensive sculpture ever sold at auction – and $179.3m for Picasso’s Les Femmes d’Alger – making it the most expensive work full stop. “Christie’s will continue in years to come to innovate more sales concepts that inspire the art collecting public,” crowed Jussi Pylkkänen, Christie’s global president and the sale’s auctioneer. You betcha. Two years later, they came up with a sales concept that netted $450m for a duff Leonardo. 

    We’re used to auction houses making silly money from modern masters, but making imbecilic money from old ones is something new. Before the advent of Leonardo’s Salvator Mundi the auction record for an old master stood at the £49.5m achieved by Rubens’ Massacre of the Innocents in 2002. To the new generation of collectors an Old Masters sale is about as sexy as a slave market of octogenarians. But despite his personal resemblance to Chronos Leonardo is an exception, largely thanks to Dan Brown – “as fascinating as any bestselling thriller” was how a Christie’s promotional video trailed the Salvator Mundi – and an escort of Warhol’s Sixty Last Suppers had a further rejuvenating effect. Plus it helped that the National Gallery had given the picture one of the best shop windows in the world by including it in its 2011 Leonardo exhibition, where it stuck out like a sore thumb (though the thumbs are two of the best things about it). Nicholas Penny and Dan Brown both deserve a commission.

    “What remains of a Rembrandt torn into four equal pieces and flushed down the toilet?” asked Jean Genet in an essay of 1967. What remains of this Leonardo? Not a lot. The painting “has endured some wear and tear over the centuries,” a spokeswoman for Christie’s conceded to The Art Newspaper before the sale, “but many of the most important elements – the blessing hand, the orb, Christ’s vestments, the curls in his hair – are remarkably intact.” All you can say is: “Nice curls, shame about the face”.

    When a conservator devotes six years to restoring a picture that the original artist painted in a few weeks, the work is arguably more hers than his. So what am I bid for this Modestini? Without a recognised offence of ‘inappropriate retouching’, the line between restoration and fakery is as blurred as the Salvator Mundi’s face. As for the line between disruption and corruption, that keeps getting thinner and Leonardo’s crystal ball offers no hope of improvement. To quote Tom Phillips’s epitaph on Van Gogh: “Auctions speak louder than words”.