Tag: RA

  • RA summer exhibition: not all open exhibitions are cheats

    In The Jackdaw ♯8 artist Doug Lowe asked if the Royal Academy Summer Exhibition was a genuine open or an Academicians’ closed shop.

    Has anyone ever worked out the total cost to artists of a big show like the RA Summer Exhibition in time, depreciation of vehicles, fuel, parking, framing, mounting, entrance etc.? It must run into millions…

    Not all open exhibitions are cheats.  Some give seriously good odds that you will get hung if your work is competently executed and shows some creativity. My target is the RA Summer Exhibition which deludes us into thinking we have a good chance of being selected.  Being gamblers at heart (and desperate to boot) we artists naively part with our hard-earned cash, not to mention our precious time which might be better spent working than in exposing ourselves to brutalizing motorway queues and London’s permanent traffic jams.

    We suckers do our sums, calculate the odds and they seem to be reasonable.  So, from all over Britain, we trot along to Burlington Gardens with our treasured efforts. A few weeks later the rejection slip duly arrives, so we trot all the way back again to collect them.  This process reminds me of the Grand Old Duke of York. Has anyone ever worked out the total cost to artists of a big show like the RA Summer Exhibition in time, depreciation of vehicles, fuel, parking, framing, mounting, entrance etc.? It must run into millions.

    What irritates is not so much what the organisers tell us, it is what they don’t tell us. But if we hang around long enough, it slowly penetrates our thick skulls that we are suckers and that we would be better advised to put our paintings into a local art show where we might not gain fame and fortune, but at least we might sell something. Face it fellow artists, the queue in the line for fame and fortune stretches around the globe and the chances of your paintings or mine being selected is much more remote than you think.

    Having had three rejections in a row, I decided to do some calculations. I studied both the 1999 and 2000 catalogues. The statistics for both are similar. Last year about 13,000 paintings were submitted from around 5,000 artists. 1,156 works were displayed. This means that you had an 11/1 chance of being hung – reasonable odds you might think. Not so. Academicians (RAs) are entitled to hang six paintings, as against the rest of us who can only submit three. So most of them do just that. If this is an open exhibition, how is it that the Academicians get twice as many as everyone else? If they want an Academicians’ show surely they have sufficient power within the Academy  (since they run it!) to mount such a self-promoting exercise. Why elbow out no-hopers like me when they are already miles out in front? With their unfair advantage,  Academicians should be barred from the show, let alone be allowed six works each.

    We are told that all submissions are viewed anonymously. This is absurd. How do the selectors manage to choose six Academician’s paintings to our possible three if they aren’t clearly identified? Are they all so distinguished and well known to the selectors that the judging panel can bull’s eye every Academician’s painting submitted without knowing their identity? I doubt it.

    If 5,000 artists submitted works for selection but 93 Academicians’ work were selected this represents just 2% of the artists submitting work. They got in 4.7 works each amounting to 38% of the total exhibits. You might have thought that this leaves space for a mere 7,219 works for the rest of us, but it doesn’t. The actual number from outside is far fewer than this because in order to improve the standard of the exhibition certain artists are invited to show works, a practice which further eats into the diminishing space allocated the rest of us.  This year the Damiens and Traceys are being invited to show by the chief hanger, their  “friend” Peter Blake RA, at a time when these types of trendy artists already enjoy so many opportunities to exhibit elsewhere. This is only the tip of the iceberg. What it doesn’t tell us is how much of the gallery space is given to Academicians. They exhibit 38% of the paintings but take up 66% of the exhibition space, excluding the courtyard (100%). If that isn’t cheating I’d like to know what is. And it doesn’t tell you that the Academicians get the prime spaces like Gallery 3, the biggest and airiest gallery, 86% of the space; Central Hall 100% and Lecture Room 100%.

    So, many fewer than 700 works, 62% of the paintings get stuffed into well under a third of the space. If you’re not getting it, the message is that the Royal Academy is taking advantage of the rabble – you and me – outside the gates.

    Now it starts to hurt: 529 hopefuls get one or two works each hung which represents 10% of submitting artists but now the odds of any one painting being exhibited are extended to 27/1. These odds are bad enough if your paintings are small but if you paint anything bigger than two feet square, you have to fight it out with other artists for 239 spaces. This increases the odds of being selected to 54/1. The National Lottery is more fun and doesn’t cost £18 per work to enter.

    Another gripe, although I have to admit it is not a factor which discourages me from entering,  is the Summer Exhibition as a nice little earner. How about this for a jump start to a show: 13,000 paintings at £18 each totals £234,000.  Not bad as revenue before you’ve even started selling. I guess you have to deduct non-payment of the submission fee,  £108 each, for the privileged Academicians.  [No you don’t. They pay too. Ed]

    It goes on: why do Academicians get capitals for their catalogue entry? And how come 93 Academicians out of a total of around 115 get selected? Presumably the rest couldn’t be bothered to enter otherwise they would have been included as well. This really stinks of establishment backscratching. Does this mean that Academicians from all of the other schools and academies in the UK are obviously inferior? And where does all this leave the self-taught artists of proven ability; those,  incidentally, who can knock spots off some of the hackneyed Academicians whose work hasn’t changed in decades.

    So the arts are like every other sphere of life: it’s not what you know or how good you are, it’s instead all about living in London and being able to press the right buttons to open doors. No wonder so many deserving artists can’t be bothered with any of this and just shut it out and get on with their work.

     The Jackdaw Sept-Oct 2011

  • RA summer exhibition: plus ca change

    PLUS CA CHANGE: In The Jackdaw ♯10, over ten years ago, anonymous artist ‘Trimmer’ responded to the inclusion of guests of the young British artists who are now, coincidentally, themselves nearly all Royal Academicians:

    Effectively, a whole generation of painters has been erased from the art scene, precisely because they hold some principles and adhere to some form of expression and development within their work that is not bounded by fashion.

    As a practicing artist, with work in both private and public collections and a long track record of exhibiting and selling work (since 1985), it is with some trepidation that each year I, like many others, enter works for the RA Summer Show. For many artists this is a good opportunity not only to sell but also to reach a wider audience.

    Over the years I have sold a number of works through the Summer Exhibition and these sales have led to further sales, via word of mouth.  This summer [2001], although all three of my works were not included in The Beard’s  [Peter Blake’s] show, I still have a number of outstanding appointments at the studio with people who want to purchase paintings, precisely because they have seen my work in previous Summer Shows.

    Before making the following rant and in order to check that the works I submitted this year were of a high standard, I deliberately entered works that were made at the same point in time as the last selection of works I entered for the Summer Exhibition. According to my own criteria, the works I entered this year were of an equal standard to works previously selected, shown and sold. So, we know in my case, the paintings submitted were very good. This is not only my rating but, more importantly, the rating of previous selectors of the exhibition.

    However, I know my works were graded as either doubtful or rejected by the selector(s), I, like many others get to turn nasty. This year’s show displays a total disregard, almost a contempt for artists who do not enjoy privileged connections. The decision to include the YBA crowd in the show may have annoyed many RAs, but not half as much as it annoys artists like myself. I now realise that I do not fall into any of the following categories:

    a) I know someone on the selection panel.

    b) I am an elected RA.

    c) My work is included because it could raise the profile of the show and increase media coverage.

    d) I live in LA and did my best work many years ago.

    e) I am an RA student or an ex-RA student.

    f) I am an ex-RA student/RA student who is helping to hang the show.

    g) I have made a small painting in a kitsch style of Princess Diana, or Trevor Brooking, and been lucky to have this work selected for novelty reasons.

    There is now no alternative to painters working in a free sense, to show their work. Painting is in fact dead. Effectively, a whole generation of painters has been erased from the art scene, precisely because they hold some principles and adhere to some form of expression and development within their work which is not bounded by fashion.

    The main cause for this sad state of affairs is the refusal of those in the art world who were nurtured in the 1960s to relinquish control of the precious academy, their mortgage-funding jobs in art schools and their dedication to not walking the line. All very English and boring but nevertheless true and influential in the most debilitating way upon the careers of younger artists, or even established artists who walk a different line.

    One of the most fundamental principles with regard to education, is the transmission of information/knowledge from one generation to another, so that ideas can progress and develop in a rational way. When this process is interrupted, as it has been in UK art schools for the last twenty years, we are left with the current situation, where a group of isolated elders desperately seek credibility among the YBAs, who, to be frank, laugh in their faces.

    The idea that Pop Art still has influence in the art world may seem ludicrous, but the same painter, The Beard [Peter Blake], who headed the selection committee for this year’s summer show simultaneously has two paintings hung at Tate Britain. The notion that these two facts are unrelated is not tenable.

    Corruption/collusion/conspiracy is nothing new but it is very depressing and ultimately wrong.

    David Lee

    The Jackdaw Sept-Oct 2011

  • Can the RA summer exhibition still be considered an open submission show?

    … Painter Patrick Cullen supplies damning evidence that the answer is ‘No!’

    A detailed survey of 2011’s Royal Academy Summer Exhibition reveals that the non-members’ work now represents only 29% of the total exhibition if measured by the amount of wall space it commands. This is in contrast to a figure of 78% estimated for the same show exactly one hundred years ago.

    In 1911 the basic format of the exhibition was the same as now: the RAs could choose to have up to six works hung (still the case), and the public could submit three for consideration (this also remained the case right up to 2008 when the Academy decided to limit to two the number of works eligible for non members to submit). But in 1911 it was seen very much as an exhibition for those non-members. At that time many of the RAs chose not to submit at all and on average they put in 2.6 works apiece as compared with 4 today. (In 1911 just six RAs put in their full quota of 6 paintings, in 2011 44 of the current RAs did so.) Consequently in 1911 87% of the paintings hung in the exhibition were by non-members. We also know from photographs of the time that, although the RAs had the privilege of having their work shown  “on the line” (at eye level), the show was otherwise much less hierarchical and more democratic than today. All exhibitors were treated alike with regard to the amount of space around their pictures  (not much!) and the range spanning the biggest and smallest paintings was much less than is now the case. The bigger paintings were certainly not all by members. Even if we assume that on average the Academicians’ paintings were twice as large as the public’s and given that the RAs had only 13% of the total number of paintings, we end up with a figure of 22% for their share of the wall-space.

    How different today! Not only has the number of paintings by the RAs increased to 40% of the show but they now occupy 71% of the wall-space. The chart summarizes these changes. The figures for 1961 suggest they have been part of a steady development over the past 100 years.

    For ease of comparison this survey is restricted to paintings, prints,  drawings and all two dimensional works hung on the gallery walls  (referred to below as “paintings” for short). Sculpture, all 3D works and all architectural plans and models have not been included.  ‘Hon members’ include all affiliated Fellows, Members and Academicians, plus recently deceased members shown in the exhibition of that year.

    What the chart shows is that the Summer Show has gradually over this period become much more of a showcase for the RAs themselves than it is for those submitting work from the general public (or the  “send-ins”). This is connected to four other changes:

    1. The number of RAs has increased from 70 in 1911 to 80 in 1961 and to 116 today. There are also a lot more honorary and affiliated members exhibiting now as well as invited international artists. Plus the exhibition space has slightly decreased, gallery 11 making way for the RA shop, and the sculpture gallery also lost to redevelopment.

    2. The RAs, whether out of hubris or sheer creative confidence, are submitting much larger works year on year, culminating in the biggest artwork ever displayed at the Academy, David Hockney’s “Bigger Trees”– oil on 50 canvases – in 2007. It is hard to see any reason, other than pure vanity, why Hockney, one of the biggest international stars in the Academy’s firmament with plenty of other arenas to strut his stuff, should choose to crowd out 49 other canvasses at an open submission exhibition.

    3. The RAs are also hanging themselves a lot more generously in terms of space than that which they accord the “send-ins”. An extreme example of this trend is this year’s Lecture Room hang by Michael Craig-Martin often regarded as the Godfather of the YBAs. He has made this a no-go area for non members and though it’s a large room,  the walls are sparingly hung with just 16 works (and two against-the wall sculptures). It is worrying that this trend is being forged by the younger generation of RAs, Tracey Emin pulling off the same trick the year after she was elected when she hung Gallery 8 in similar style entirely with her friends’ work. The result may well be a more  “consistent hang” with each art work benefitting hugely from all the space around it, but it has nothing to do with the spirit of the Summer Exhibition, simply turning it instead into any other mixed show of successful artists that can be seen in galleries, public and private, all the year round. By contrast Gallery 1 (small prints) and the Small Weston Room (small oils) are hung in the salon style with hundreds of little works cheek by jowl. Needless to say 80% of these are nonmembers works. These two crowded rooms account for just 11% of the total exhibition wall space but for over 50% of the works accepted from the general public.

    4. The other side of this coin: the RAs are accepting fewer and smaller paintings from the public send-in. They recently reduced the maximum number of works the public could submit from 3 to 2. This was justified on the grounds that the send-in was getting too large to cope with. In fact it would be truer to say that they wanted to select fewer works and had been doing so for some time in order to allow for the expanded number of RAs, their even more expanded canvases and their desire to be hung more flatteringly. Why, it might be asked, did they not reduce the number of paintings they allow themselves? Either that, or put a limit on the square acreage of canvas allowed to each member.

    It boils down to a question of what the Summer Show is for. The RA likes to boast that it’s the biggest open exhibition in the world, but can it really claim this when over 70% of the walls are occupied by the club members who do not have to submit their work for selection at all? If they gave the show back to the public as it was in 1911, all the indications are that it would be more popular not less.  Sales in the Small Weston Room are, as always, over 85%; in the rest of the show they are more like 21%. Of course the critics would return to lambasting it (apart from Craig-Martin’s room the show still got little praise anyway this year). An open exhibition like this must always be a mish-mash and can never be cutting edge or cool, unless of course it abandons all pretence at being open. The trouble is that the new in-take of RAs who are now in the driving seat (40 of the old guard are now Senior Academicians – 75 or older – and as such lose all voting and selection rights), want the show to become more like Craig-Martin’s Lecture Room not less. The Small Weston Room and the kind of art it represents – conservative, unpretentious, small scale, mostly observational painting – is something whose disappearance they would not shed any tears over.

    The Jackdaw Sept-Oct 2011

  • The RA is not a charity

    The RA is not a charity

    Inspired by landscape painter Patrick Cullen, The Jackdaw Sept-Oct 2011 reprinted pieces about the Royal Academy that have appeared in The Jackdaw over the last eleven years. All deal with the genuine fears of artists that the Summer Exhibition is progressively a closed shop whilst being marketed as an ‘Open’. Patrick’s research succinctly reinforces previous claims made by artists that the chances of an outsider featuring in the Summer Exhibition are now so seriously diminished that no gambling man would ever accept such long odds. Justifiably over the years this has become a common lament because, as Patrick demonstrates, an inverse logic now seems to apply: as the cost of having a work considered increases (currently £25 per item) so the chance of successful selection is reduced. Even a less cynical person than myself must conclude that the Summer Exhibition has become a calculated ploy to fleece lesser-known artists, many of whom can ill-afford the submission fees in the first place. This is done in order to shore up the finances of a membership-only club many of whose beneficiaries are already well-to-do artists; indeed some are among the world’s wealthiest. This Robin-Hood-in-reverse ploy is surely a perverse betrayal for an organisation purporting to be a charity. Where the Royal Academy is concerned, it would seem that charity not only begins at home but ends there as well.

    The Academy is a registered charity whose annual accounts may be examined on the Charity Commission’s website. (Did you know, for example, that the President of the RA trousers sixty grand a year? And there I was thinking he gave his time selflessly for God, the Coalition and the dog’s bollocks of gold chains.) Notwithstanding our frequent claims in these pages that it is no longer an ‘Academy’ using any accepted definition of that term – and how can it be when a downright charlatan like Gary Hume is Professor of Painting? – I have arrived at the conclusion that it is no longer a charity either, if, that is, it ever was one. My purpose here is to demonstrate that the Royal Academy is a business, pure and simple, and bears negligible resemblance to a charity. It does less and less for artists in general and more and more for its Academicians in particular.

    My understanding of charity is doubtless an old-fashioned one. She stands among Giotto’s virtues in the Arena Chapel, the junoesque rustic dispensing grain, veg and manna to the needy. A modern equivalent is The Salvation Army, an organisation for which I have personal fondness. Somewhat of a laughing stock these days with their Victorian uniforms, simple principles and enthusiastic (if not exactly euphonious) brass bands at Christmas time, they look after the poor, lonely and deserted. They perform visible good works and they do it without living high on the hog by siphoning off donations to pay for posh offices, flamboyant places of worship or overpaid officials. They cared for two of my relatives, one of whom, a vagrant grandfather persecuted with imprisonment by those unsympathetic to his irrepressible free spirit, lived and died in a Salvation Army hostel, the last of many with which he had over 40 years of wandering become acquainted. The Army’s charitable works are conspicuous and basic – hot soup, shelter, a bunk, a bath and a kind word for the homeless.

    Using the Sally’s criterion of free giving the Royal Academy scarcely looks anything like a charity. It is a strange charity indeed whose main beneficiaries are the organisation’s own members; namely, the 116 Royal Academicians, many of the most celebrated artists of the day, for whom its Mayfair stately home functions as a gentlemans’ club.

    Exactly what services does the Academy supply to the public to deserve its charitable status? It runs an art school in its basement, much like any other for which students pay fees. It puts on exhibitions for which it extorts stiff admission charges effectively excluding all but the better off who don’t need charity anyway. It is a business which mounts exhibitions, flogs unnecessary souvenirs and feeds and waters the well-heeled. On the face of it the Royal Academy gives nothing away to anyone sufficiently disadvantaged to merit the description ‘charitable institution’.

    In its defence it doesn’t receive a farthing from the Arts Council, although there’s no reason why it shouldn’t qualify. Another ‘charity’, the Whitechapel Art Gallery, which receives £1.5 million per year in public subsidy as well as regular infusions from the National Lottery in fulfilment of seemingly permanent lebensraum ambitions, is charging a steep admission of £9.50 for its current Thomas Struth retrospective (and if you book in advance they’ll throw in lunch for thirty of forty quid apiece). What does the Whitechapel give in return for its charitable status if not free admission to the shows it mounts? I’ve sang this song before, and it’s always been received with deafening indifference, but what is a charity doing subsidising the promotion of a famous German photographer whose works are now selling at auction for over a million dollars apiece and who is represented by two of the world’s wealthiest dealers? I don’t get it. How does any of this constitute ‘charity’? The dealers themselves should be paying for the privilege of promoting their artist in this public arena in order that the Whitechapel can show the work free of charge and therefore make at least some stab at fulfilling its charitable educational responsibilities. For the duration of the Struth exhibition at least, the Whitechapel is not a charity at all, it is, like the RA, a business.

    Defenders of the Academy are ever eager to announce as loudly as they can shout it, that it receives no public subsidy, a statement that has become accepted wisdom. This is the kind of half truth many of us expect nowadays from arts organisations eager to parade their thrift, enterprise and cost-effectiveness. Needless to say, it isn’t true. There is the small matter of its premises, Burlington House, for which the Academy holds a 999-year lease (850 years of which remain) vouchsafed at a peppercorn rent by the Secretary of State for Employment, Transport and the Regions. A massive building, a palace indeed, with a suite of arguably the finest rooms in Britain, a furlong from Piccadilly Circus … What, I wonder, might the Candy brothers extract for this peach? No public subsidy? Pull the other one.

    Leaving aside its objective “to engage with the widest possible public”, which it doesn’t and never has done, in its declaration of charitable objectives the Academy states a purpose “to represent the professional interests of all artists and architects to the public and to government.” Its only real connection with “all artists” is the annual Summer Exhibition, the first of which was staged in 1769 and hung 136 works by the 34 founding members. Helping artists, whose average income incidentally is below the Government’s poverty line, is an aim worthy of a charity. But the Academy is gradually reneging even on this, for the small charitable purpose it performs in showing the work of those who have little opportunity to exhibit elsewhere is now badly eroded. The impression any outsider might form is that the Academy would, if it might get away with burying such bad news, rid itself completely of outside submissions to the Summer Exhibition, but it can’t because of the money this contributes to a precarious balance sheet.

    Details of the Summer Exhibition’s finances are omitted from the accounts so I’ve had to work them out for myself. I visited the exhibition a fortnight before it finished in order to make a record of sales. My rough figures are probably only as good as the doubtless desultory information provided.

    There were over 12,000 entries to this year’s exhibition, 1,117 of which were displayed. A thousand will have been the work of the RAs themselves. So 11,000 entries at £25 each is £275,000. Assuming that half of the average annual 150,000 attendance pay the exhibition entrance charge as non­members at £10 apiece, this delivers another £750,000. With a fortnight still to go, although one suspects the overwhelming majority of sales were long completed, the number of works sold was 3,812, of which 3,436 were editioned prints. The number of works sold by RAs was 1,004 (26%) and by outsiders 2,808 (74%). The total value of works sold was £3,199,975, of which £1,648,499 (52%) was generated by RAs. In terms of their value to the Academy, Academicians, though they sell half the number of works, are worth more than outsiders: the average cost of a sold work by an RA being £1,642 against the equivalent figure for an outsider of £553. But this doesn’t take into account the fact that the work of non-members, as Patrick Cullen demonstrates below, occupies only 29% of the overall space. (Interestingly, only 7% of the works sold are paintings and sculpture, the other 93% are editions – comprising 90% prints and 3% photographs).

    The Academy takes a 30% commission on all sales, including those of RAs – which generates another £960,000. The prima facie revenue of the Summer Exhibition, therefore, comes to ca. £1,985,000; a figure that might easily be doubled when you consider – and this may surprise you as it did me – that its shops and restaurants contribute more revenue (£9 million) than exhibition takings (£8.5 million) throughout the year. When costs are taken into account I assume the profitability of the Summer Exhibition is in the region of £3 million. To understand something of the importance of the milch cow that is the Summer Exhibition to the overall financial health of the Royal Academy, in the last published accounts the annual surplus was as low (on a turnover of £31 million) as £600,000.

    Far from reducing the number of outsiders exhibiting, the Academy should be encouraging more participation from non-members because not only would they be conforming better to their charitable purpose of representing “all artists”, but they would also make more money. With this in mind they should make more room for outsiders by ejecting the works of Honorary RAs like Jeff Koons. He and his ilk don’t need to exhibit at the Royal Academy, State Art being more than generous to them already. To have hidden in the corner of the courtyard the major work of an RA sculptor, James Butler, whilst giving prominence to the already over­-exhibited gaudy tat of Koons was an insulting mistake. Is promoting Koons, or Ruscha, or Kiefer, really consistent with the Academy’s charitable status? No it isn’t, indeed it is completely unjustified and inconsistent with it. Likewise, the now accepted practice of inviting artists, usually the friends of RAs, should also be stopped for it is a naked scam. The space released should be given to more of those from the open submission.

    Furthermore, in order to rectify the system by which poorer artists have their pockets rifled in order to keep the RAs in the club to which they have become accustomed, the Academy should charge RAs 40% or even 50% commission on sales. This is the least of what they would pay an art dealer. An increased figure for RAs would allow a reduction to the existing 30% for those not fortunate to be members. This would enable the Academy to fulfil one function of any charity, this being the voluntary redistribution of wealth from those who are prosperous to those who struggle.

    If the Royal Academy doesn’t wish to help more artists by showing and selling their work, and thereby allowing them a better than basic living, its bogus charitable status should be removed and it should be re­classified as the business it is and taxed as such. At the moment it serves no obvious charitable function.

    http://www.patrickcullen.co.uk/

    http://www.royalacademy.org.uk/exhibitions/summer-exhibition-2012/

    David Lee

    The Jackdaw Sept-Oct 2011